1611 W PAINT PONY Drive, Payson, AZ 85541

$430,000

Property Type: Residential Bedrooms: 2 Baths: 1 Lot Size (sq. ft.): 457,380 Status: Closed

Current Price: $430,000 Last Modified: 2/08/2026

Overview

Description

10+/- acres of beautiful secluded horse property with two fenced pastures, a 6 stall Mare Motel, all nestled between the National Forest and the seasonal Webber Creek. A private well, and a 760+/- sqft 2 bedroom, 1 bath home. Covered porch on two sides. Two small Bunkhouses. A secluded hideaway to relax, enjoy your privacy and your horses. Must cross Webber creek-bed to get to property. New well pump (2017), New retaining wall, New tile flooring, Furniture & Generator can be negotiated for sale outside of escrow. Some of the Horses & Tack may be negotiated for sale outside of escrow (Gypsy Vanner horses will not be sold). Padlocked gate at property line. Buyer to verify that property is in Flood Zone D.

Listing Details MLS# 5961077

Location, Tax & Legal

Map Code/Grid: C71
House Number: 1611
Compass: W
Street Name: PAINT PONY
St Suffix: Drive
City/Town Code: Payson
State/Province: AZ
Zip Code: 85541
Country: US
County Code: Gila
Assessor Number: 302-13-014-A
Subdivision: Geronimo Estates
Tax Year: 2018

Contract Information

Type: Exclusive Right To Sell
Ownership: Fee Simple

General Property Description

Dwelling Type: Single Family Residence
Dwelling Styles: Detached
Exterior Stories: Yes
# of Interior Levels: Yes
# Bedrooms: 2
Total Bathrooms: Yes
Approx SQFT: 760
Price/SqFt: 565.79
Horses: Y
Builder Name: Unknown
Year Built: 1979
Approx Lot SqFt: 457380
Community Pool Y/N: No
Private Pool Y/N: No
Fireplace YN: No
Elementary School: Out of Maricopa Cnty
Jr. High School: Out of Maricopa Cnty
High School: Out of Maricopa Cnty

Remarks Misc

Cross Street: FSR 64 (Control Road) & FSR 458 (Munsee Dr)
Directions: Payson North on Hwy87 Right on Houston Mesa Rd., Left on FSR 64 (control rd) 4mi to Geronimo Estates, left on FSR 458 (Munsee Dr.) Left on Paint Pony, .5 mi to sign, cross creek-bed, to gate.

Status Change Info

Off Market Date: 2019-08-25
Under Contract Date: 2019-08-24
Close of Escrow Date: 2019-10-04

Legal Info

Township: 11
Range: 10E
Section: 19
Lot Number: 014A

More Information

Basement

Basement Y/N: N

Items Updated

Floor Yr Updated: 2018
Floor Partial/Full: Partial
Roof Yr Updated: 2018
Roof Partial/Full: Partial

Contact Info

List Agent Home Phn: 623-261-6048

Sold Info

Loan Type: Cash
Payment Type: Other
Closing Cost Split: Seller Paid - S
Buyer Concession $/%: $
Seller Concession $/%: $

Property Features

Special Listing Cond: N/A Add'l Property Use: Farm; Ranch Architecture: Ranch View: Mountain(s) Master Bathroom: None Flooring: Carpet; Tile Spa: None Dining Area: Breakfast Bar Kitchen Features: Gas Oven; Gas Range; Refrigerator; Granite Counters Laundry: Washer Included; Dryer Included; Inside Interior Features: Furnished(See Rmrks) Technology: Pre-Wire Sat Dish Exterior Features: Storage; Other Parking Features: Unassigned Construction: Wood Frame Const - Finish: Painted; Siding Roofing: Rolled Cooling: Ceiling Fan(s) Heating: Other; See Remarks Plumbing: Electric Hot Wtr Htr Utilities: APS; Propane Water Source: Private Well Sewer: Septic-In & Connected Fencing: Wire; Partial; See Remarks Property Description: Borders Preserve/Public Land; Waterfront Lot Landscaping: Natural Desert Front; Natural Desert Back Horse Features: Barn; Tack Room Showing Notification Methods: Text Lockbox Type: Supra Possession: Close of Escrow Unit Style: All on One Level Association Fee Incl: No Fees Existing 1st Loan: Treat as Free&Clear New Financing: Cash; Conventional Disclosures: Seller Discl Avail; Agency Discl Req

Listing Office: ERA-Young Realty & Investment

Office Phone: 928-474-4554

Last Updated: February - 08 - 2026